Tuesday 15 September 1998
St Patrick’s Cathedral, East Melbourne
Melbourne Early Music Festival
With Concentus Australis
PROGRAM
Johann Sebastian Bach St John Passion
Gerald English, Evangelist
Margaret Pearce, Soprano
David V Russell, Alto
Adrian Dwyer, Tenor
Michael Leighton Jones, Bass
Stephen Grant, Jesus
Choir members unknown
REVIEW
Friday 18 September, The Herald Sun [Melbourne], page 38.
Bach an inspired first night choice
Johanna Selleck
ST Patrick’s Cathedral echoed to the immortal strains of Bach’s St John Passion on Tuesday.
Though this work was the master’s earliest essay in the genre, it was written at the height of his artistic
powers.
An inspired and all-encompassing expression of deepest humanity, it provided exactly the sort of direct and
vivid statement that was needed to make an impact on the opening night of the Early Music Festival.
The team of soloists, the orchestra of Concentus Australis and the choir of Ensemble Gombert gelled under
the expert direction of John O’Donnell. In particular, the graphic realism of Bach’s setting was captured by
Gerald English’s animated, incisive delivery as the Evangelist.
His narration was powerfully offset by Stephen Grant’s mellow portrayal of Jesus, and by some excellent
characterisations on the part of soprano Margaret Pearce, alto David Russell, tenor Adrian Dwyer and bass
Michael Leighton Jones.
Bach employs distinctive instrumental groupings to color the mood of individual arias. Flutes are made to
melt sensuously into the soaring soprano lines, or the tenor voice is cushioned by sombre, softly spoken
strings and organ.
These moments were captured sensitively by Concentus Australis on period instruments. The silken
sonorities of the baroque instruments blend with a subtlety not possible on modern equivalents.
While the orchestra maintained an air of rapt solemnity and pathos, the choir battled to make their presence
felt in the resonant cathedral acoustic which disseminated the sound all too effectively.
Consequently, the dramatic choruses lacked solidity and definition, not because of lack of choral expertise,
but the need for larger forces, given the surroundings.
The festival continues until Sunday with a diverse program that is sure to please connoisseur and ordinary
listener alike.
Friday 18 September, The Australian [Sydney], page 17. (extract)
Unlikely duo lifts the class
Jeremy Vincent
This year’s Melbourne Early Music Festival kicked off with a carefully delivered performance of Bach’s St John Passion in St Patrick’s Cathedral. O’Donnell’s diligent approach to his art mustered a decidedly sedate and proper reading, featuring Concentus Australis, the Ensemble Gombert choir and a group of fine soloists.
The venue was rather too large for an ideal balance. All credit, then, to the conductor for taming the
musicians enough to allow the choir plenty of show. The soloists were generally in good form, although a couple struggled to communicate their lower notes, especially as the acoustic tended to turn the continuo into almost a growling accompaniment.